The Effect of Brand–Cause Fit on Consumer Skepticism toward CSR Initiatives: The Moderating Role of Perceived Transparency in CSR Communication

(2026)

Files

Matheys_18192000_2026.pdf
  • Open access
  • Adobe PDF
  • 1.73 MB

Details

Supervisors
Faculty
Degree label
Abstract
Consumer skepticism toward corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives has become a major challenge for organizations seeking to communicate their societal commitments. Previous research has identified brand–cause fit, defined as the perceived congruence between a brand and the CSR cause it supports, and perceived transparency in CSR communication as important antecedents of consumer skepticism. However, their combined effect remains unexplored. Therefore, this study investigates whether perceived transparency moderates the relationship between brand–cause fit and consumer skepticism toward CSR initiatives. To address this question, a 2 × 2 between-subjects experiment was conducted among 220 participants. Brand–cause fit and perceived transparency were manipulated through CSR communication scenarios, while consumer skepticism served as the primary dependent variable. The results indicate that higher brand–cause fit significantly reduces consumer skepticism. By contrast, perceived transparency neither exerted a significant direct effect nor moderated the relationship between brand–cause fit and consumer skepticism. However, a sensitivity analysis was conducted using stricter manipulation-check criteria. When the analysis was restricted to participants whose perceptions were consistent with the intended manipulations, perceived transparency had a significant negative effect on consumer skepticism. Two complementary analyses were also conducted. First, the effects of brand–cause fit, perceived transparency, and their interaction were further examined with brand message authenticity as the dependent variable. The findings mirrored those obtained for consumer skepticism, providing further insight into consumer evaluations of CSR initiatives. Second, a mediation analysis was conducted to examine whether consumers' attributions of corporate motives explain the relationship between brand–cause fit and consumer skepticism. The results indicate that strategic motive attributions partially mediate this relationship, providing further insight into the psychological mechanisms underlying consumer skepticism. Overall, the findings extend the existing literature by providing a more nuanced understanding of how consumers evaluate CSR initiatives. They further suggest that organizations should prioritize CSR initiatives perceived as coherent with their brand while using transparency as a complementary rather than compensatory communication strategy.